Where carriers contradict themselves
two documents, two answers

Carriers publish the same rule in more than one place, and the places do not always agree. This page quotes each pair side by side, with links to both documents and the value that we use.

Documents checked: 4 November 2026

Summary

7 places where the documents disagree

Each item below quotes two documents from the same carrier or seller. The two documents give different values for the same thing. We checked each document on 4 November 2026 or on the date in the change log.

#Carrier or sellerTopic
1FedExRounding of package dimensions
2UPSWhy there are two DIM divisors
3USPSDIM divisor for nonrectangular parcels
4USPSOutside length of the Small Flat Rate Box
5USPSOutside length of the Medium Flat Rate Box 2 (side-loading)
6FedExSize and weight limit of the FedEx Large Box
7The Home DepotSize of the Extra Large Moving Box (model 1001015)

NOTE: These are not always errors. Different teams keep different documents. But a support answer and an invoice can come from different documents, so the difference can cost you money.

Details

The quotes, side by side

1. FedEx: Rounding of package dimensions

FedEx Service Guide 2026, p. 135
Any fraction of an inch is rounded up to the next-higher inch.
FedEx: What is dimensional weight
Round each measurement to the nearest whole inch.

What we use: Round up. The Service Guide is the contract document.

Why it matters: A 12.3 in side bills as 13 in, not 12 in. On a box near a DIM limit, this adds 1 lb or more.

2. UPS: Why there are two DIM divisors

UPS: Shipping dimensions and weight
139 for Daily Rates and 166 for Retail Rates (by rate type).
UPS 2026 Rate and Service Guide (Retail Rates)
166 for domestic and 139 for export (by destination).

What we use: 139 for Daily Rates, 166 for Retail Rates (domestic).

Why it matters: The numbers agree. The reason differs, so a support answer and an invoice can seem to disagree.

3. USPS: DIM divisor for nonrectangular parcels

USPS DMM 223 §1.4.3
Priority Mail divides the volume of a nonrectangular parcel by 166.
USPS DMM 283 §1.4.3
Ground Advantage (commercial) divides the volume of a nonrectangular parcel by 139.

What we use: 166 for Priority Mail, 139 for Ground Advantage. Rectangular parcels use 139 for both.

Why it matters: The same tube or bag bills at a different DIM weight with each service.

6. FedEx: Size and weight limit of the FedEx Large Box

FedEx One Rate (US)
12 3/8 × 3 × 17 1/2 in. One Rate boxes must weigh less than 50 lb.
FedEx Large Box (FedEx Dominican Republic site)
Inside: 17.88 × 12.38 × 3 in. Maximum weight 20 lb.

What we use: The US One Rate values, because the comparator uses US services.

Why it matters: 3/8 in of length, and a weight limit of 20 lb or 50 lb, depending on the page.

Procedure

What to do when two documents disagree

  1. Find the contract document. For FedEx and UPS, this is the Service Guide or the Rate and Service Guide.
  2. Use the contract document for an invoice dispute.
  3. Quote the page number and the date of the document.
  4. Keep a copy of the page, because carriers change their pages without notice.

Dated rule changes are in the carrier rule change log. The same list is in the carrier rules dataset as contradictions.json.

Report

Report a contradiction

Did you find two carrier documents that disagree? Send both links to contactus@boxvolumecalculator.com. We add an item after we read both documents.

FAQ

Questions

Does FedEx round dimensions up or to the nearest inch?
The FedEx Service Guide 2026 says to round up to the next inch. The FedEx page What is dimensional weight says to round to the nearest inch. The Service Guide is the contract document, so use it for an invoice dispute.
Why does UPS have two DIM divisors?
UPS uses 139 for Daily Rates and 166 for Retail Rates. The Retail Rate and Service Guide describes the same numbers as 166 for domestic and 139 for export.
Which document should I use when carrier documents disagree?
Use the contract document, for example the Service Guide. Quote its page number and date, and keep a copy of the page.
Are the USPS Flat Rate box sizes on usps.com correct?
The inside sizes agree. On the Priority Mail page, the Small Flat Rate Box is 8 1/16 in long outside. This is shorter than its inside length, so it is a typo. The Postal Store gives 8 11/16 in.